Social Cohesion Psychology: Why Australia’s National Mood Has Turned Sour

Social Cohesion Psychology: Why Australia’s National Mood Has Turned Sour

Reviewed by a Psychology Postgraduate (MA)

On Thursday 5 November 2026, the Scanlon Foundation Research Institute published its 2026 Mapping Social Cohesion Survey of 10,000 participants — and the picture is bleak. Thirty-two percent of Australians now think their lives are about to get a little or a lot worse — more than double the 14% recorded during the Covid-19 lockdowns. Half of Australian adults are now pessimistic or very pessimistic about the country’s future, up from 24% in the lockdowns.

Social cohesion psychology explains how a whole country’s mood can turn this quickly. It studies how trust, belonging and shared identity hold a society together — and what happens when those bonds fray. Moods, once they take hold, change how people treat each other and how hopeful they feel in the morning.

Reported by AAP via the Otago Daily Times on 5 November 2026, the survey also found two-thirds of respondents saying too many immigrants are not adopting Australian values, with support for migration falling. Cost-of-living pressures and events like the Bondi massacre have soured attitudes and driven distrust higher. Australian National University researcher James O’Donnell noted that shrill debates abroad are trickling into Australian discourse. The numbers are about trust — and whether Australians still believe the country works for people like them.

What did the Scanlon survey actually find?

The survey is one of the longest-running measures of Australian public feeling. Its latest edition found:

  • 32% of Australians expect their own lives to get a little or a lot worse — more than double the 14% recorded during the Covid-19 lockdowns and recession.
  • 50% of Australian adults are pessimistic or very pessimistic about the country’s future, compared with 24% during the lockdowns.
  • Two-thirds of respondents said too many immigrants are not adopting Australian values.
  • Support for migration has fallen across several measures.
  • Cost-of-living pressures and events like the Bondi massacre have soured attitudes and driven distrust higher.

During the pandemic — fear, job losses, closed borders, locked-down cities — only one in four Australians felt pessimistic about the country’s future. Now one in two does.

What is social cohesion?

Social cohesion is the sense that people in a society belong together, trust each other, and share enough common ground to get along — the glue that makes strangers behave like neighbours.

That glue has two ingredients: trust — the belief that other people and institutions will generally act fairly — and belonging, the feeling that we are part of something shared. When both are strong, societies absorb shocks; when they weaken, even ordinary disagreements start to feel like threats.

Robert Putnam, whose work on social capital shaped this field, distinguished two kinds of connection. “Bonding” social capital ties us to people like us — family, close friends, our community. “Bridging” social capital connects us to people who are different from us. A healthy society needs both: bonding alone turns tight circles inward and suspicious, while bridging keeps a diverse country feeling like one country.

Why does pessimism spread faster than optimism?

If the numbers feel surprising — worse now than during a pandemic — there is a reason: bad news weighs more heavily than good news.

Psychologists call this the negativity bias. Study after study finds negative information grabs our attention faster, sticks in memory longer, and influences our judgments more than positive information of equal size. A single frightening headline outweighs a week of steady good news. Our brains are wired this way because noticing threats quickly once kept us alive — but when threats arrive constantly, the same wiring can leave a whole population feeling under siege even when daily life is mostly stable.

The availability heuristic makes this worse: when we judge how common or dangerous something is, we lean on whatever examples come to mind most easily — a violent event dominating the news, a string of headlines about rising prices. The quieter truths, like the neighbour who helped you carry groceries, never make the news, so they never enter the calculation.

Why is trust declining in Australia?

The cost of living is the most direct pressure: when groceries, rent, energy bills and interest rates climb at once, everyday life becomes an exercise in arithmetic — and the arithmetic often does not add up. Financial strain also narrows attention: research on scarcity shows that when money is tight, people focus on immediate problems, grow less patient, and judge others less generously. It is not selfishness; it is cognitive load — a brain busy calculating whether the rent will clear has less room left for empathy.

Take Sarah, a nurse in her forties in suburban Brisbane, who earns a decent wage and never worried about money. This year her rent went up twice, her grocery bill is a third higher, and her adult son moved back home because he cannot afford a place of his own. Nothing catastrophic has happened, but the feeling of moving forward has gone — and when she hears the country is doing fine, it does not match what she feels at the checkout.

Then there is the identity side. Social identity theory, developed by Henri Tajfel, showed that people naturally sort themselves into groups — us and them. When a society feels secure, those boundaries soften; when people feel threatened, they harden, and the out-group starts to look like the problem. The finding that two-thirds of Australians feel too many immigrants are not adopting Australian values is best read this way: a measure of how many people see the world through a threatened, in-group lens. Psychology explains the pattern; it does not endorse the attitude or condemn those who hold it.

Is this just about money, or is something deeper happening?

The short answer is both: cost-of-living pressure is the spark, but the fuel was already there.

Australia has been through a remarkable run of disruption: pandemic, bushfires, floods, a housing crisis, and a cost-of-living squeeze that has lasted longer than most people expected. Each event alone is manageable, but stacked together they create what psychologists call cumulative stress — the slow wearing-down from many small blows, with no real recovery in between. During the lockdowns there was at least a shared story: we are all in this together, and it will end. Today there is no single story and no clear ending — and that uncertainty is itself exhausting.

This is where learned helplessness comes in. Martin Seligman’s classic research showed that when people repeatedly experience events they cannot control, they can start to believe nothing they do matters — and stop trying. At a national level, the equivalent is a population that stops believing voting, saving or participating will change anything — a belief more damaging than any single policy failure, because it erodes the participation that keeps a democracy healthy. The counterweight is agency: the sense that our actions still count.

What helps when a whole country feels this way?

The good news is that social cohesion can be rebuilt from the bottom up. Trust is mostly restored in small, local, repeated interactions.

Start with one bridging connection. The strongest antidote to in-group suspicion is contact — real, ordinary contact with people outside your usual circle. Decades of contact theory show it reduces prejudice more reliably than any argument. Join a local club, volunteer, or talk properly with a neighbour you have only ever waved at.

Shrink the news diet, widen the life diet. If negativity bias and the availability heuristic are feeding your pessimism, the fix is partly about what you feed your attention. Limit news and social media to a set time each day, and notice the ordinary evidence of things working: the bus that arrived on time, the colleague who helped. This is not denial — it corrects a biased sample.

Do one small thing that proves agency. Learned helplessness is broken by evidence that action matters. Pick something small — fixing a problem at work, helping a neighbour, starting a savings habit — and follow through. Small wins rebuild the belief that effort counts.

Protect the shared spaces. Libraries, sports clubs, parks and community halls are where bridging social capital is built — a country is the sum of its shared spaces.

Pause and ask yourself: When you think about your country’s future, what shapes that feeling — your daily life, or this week’s headlines? What is one thing in your neighbourhood that still works well?

If money worries are a big part of the heaviness you feel, you are far from alone — the survey suggests that is true for millions of Australians. Our Burnout + Money-Stress Check is a free, anonymous check-in that helps you map your stress and find a calmer next step.

Frequently asked questions

What is social cohesion psychology? Social cohesion psychology studies how trust, belonging and shared identity hold a society together — and what happens when those bonds weaken.

Why are Australians more pessimistic now than during the Covid lockdowns? The Scanlon Foundation’s 2026 survey found 50% pessimism, versus 24% during the lockdowns — the result of cumulative stress, cost-of-living pressure, negativity bias, and the loss of the shared “we are in this together” story of the pandemic.

Does the survey mean Australia is becoming less welcoming? Support for migration has fallen across several measures, and two-thirds of respondents felt too many immigrants are not adopting Australian values — a signal of how trust and group identity shift under strain, not a verdict on any community.

What can ordinary people do to rebuild trust? Research points to small, local actions: contact outside your usual circle, protecting shared community spaces, limiting doomscrolling, and small steps that restore agency. Trust is rebuilt in everyday interactions, not national debates.

Try it on our site

If this article struck a chord, try one of our free, anonymous tools:

Related reading: the psychology of layoffs and job insecurity, how a retail collapse shakes our sense of stability, and interest rate rise anxiety and what it does to the mind.

Key Takeaways

  • The Scanlon Foundation’s 2026 survey of 10,000 Australians found 32% expect their lives to get worse and 50% are pessimistic about the country’s future — far worse than during lockdowns.
  • Social cohesion is the trust and belonging that hold a society together; it weakens when people feel financially squeezed, threatened or unheard.
  • Negativity bias and the availability heuristic make bad news weigh more than good news, so a country’s mood can turn faster than its circumstances.
  • Trust is rebuilt from the bottom up: bridging contact, protected shared spaces, and small acts that restore agency.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice, diagnosis or treatment. If you are struggling, please speak to a licensed professional. In Australia, Lifeline is available 24 hours a day on 13 11 14.

Leave a Comment