Canada-US Trade Talks: The Psychology of Waiting for a Deal That Keeps Moving

Reviewed by a Psychology Postgraduate (MA)

The short answer

Canada-US trade talks picked up slightly on October 26, 2026, but reports disagree about whether a deal on steel and auto tariffs will come before the November 3 midterm elections. That disagreement is the point: for workers and businesses, uncertainty itself is the stressor, because the brain treats an unresolved threat as an ongoing emergency, and the way through is to plan for more than one outcome instead of waiting for one answer.

What happened in the trade talks?

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said on Monday, October 26, 2026, that trade talks with the administration of United States President Donald Trump had picked up slightly, but that any progress was because Washington was moving closer to Canada’s position. “To the extent any progress has been made, it’s because the US is coming closer to our position,” Carney said. He described a “slight, slight intensification” of discussions, and said Canada’s negotiating position had not changed.

The background is a trade dispute that broke down in August 2026. Canada rejected an offer from Washington that month after, in Carney’s words, it crossed Canada’s “red lines.” Trump then imposed 50 percent tariffs on roughly $20 billion in Canadian goods, prompting retaliation and further restrictions. Trump said on Friday, October 23, that he would lift some of those 50 percent tariffs while imposing new tariffs on dozens of other products. Two days later, at a Michigan campaign rally, he said Canada was “willing to give us anything at this moment” and that a deal would be settled “pretty soon.” He told a Detroit television station that an agreement could come before the midterm elections, although it might take months.

On Tuesday, October 27, 2026, Reuters reported, via the Japan Times, that the United States and Canada are working on a deal to ease US tariffs on Canadian steel and autos, citing two US and four Canadian sources. The talks focus on tariffs imposed under Section 232 of US trade law, including up to 50 percent on Canadian steel and 25 percent on autos, with negotiators discussing potential relief. One Canadian source briefed on the negotiations said a deal on steel and auto tariffs was possible before the November 3 elections, while US sources said the Trump administration wanted Canada to make further concessions. The sources spoke on condition of anonymity because the talks are private.

At the same time, a conflicting report points the other way. Canada’s public broadcaster CBC reported on Monday, citing three unnamed sources, that Canadian officials told industry groups in recent weeks that no agreement is anticipated before the November 3 elections, and that there is no substantial engagement between the two sides despite ongoing contact. Canada-US Trade Minister Dominic LeBlanc later confirmed that position in a CBC interview, saying: “We have continued to remain engaged with the United States. But we’re not going to rush into some particular circumstance and agree to something that we don’t think is in Canada’s sovereign interest or economic interest.”

So what is known, and what is unconfirmed? Known: talks have intensified slightly; Canada says its red lines are unchanged; tariffs of up to 50 percent on steel and 25 percent on autos are at the center of the negotiation; the US midterm elections fall on November 3, 2026. Unconfirmed: whether a deal will actually arrive before those elections. The honest answer is that two credible-sounding accounts disagree, and nobody outside the negotiating room knows which one will prove right.

Why does uncertainty feel worse than bad news?

There is a well-established psychological finding that helps explain why this kind of week feels so draining: people often find uncertainty harder to bear than a definite bad outcome. Psychologists call this intolerance of uncertainty, and it is one of the most reliable predictors of worry. When a threat is unresolved, the brain keeps it active, scanning for new information, rehearsing scenarios, and preparing for several futures at once. A definite answer, even a painful one, lets the brain stand down. An unresolved answer keeps the alarm ringing.

The news cycle makes this worse through a pattern psychologists call intermittent reinforcement: unpredictable good and bad news hold attention far more powerfully than steady news, which is why people keep refreshing headlines even when the next update probably will not change anything.

What does trade-war anxiety look like for ordinary people?

For workers in steel, auto parts, and related industries, the anxiety is not abstract. It is a question about hours, shifts, orders, and whether a plant keeps running. For small business owners who trade across the border, it is a question about pricing a product when next month’s tariff rate is unknown. The political stakes are visible too: Reuters noted that tariffs on Canadian imports have become a political liability for Trump, with Republican candidates in border states calling for an end to the trade war.

There is also an identity layer that makes this dispute feel bigger than a tariff schedule. Trump’s repeated threats to make Canada the 51st US state turned a trade negotiation into a question about national dignity. Carney has responded by seeking new markets, with a goal of doubling Canadian exports outside the United States over the next decade, and he hosts European Union leaders in Montreal on Thursday and Friday this week. When a dispute touches identity as well as income, people worry about respect as well as money, and that worry is harder to switch off.

How do you plan when the answer keeps moving?

The psychological research points to one practical shift: stop waiting for a single answer and start planning for a small set of scenarios. Psychologists call this contingency planning, and it works precisely because it gives the brain what uncertainty takes away, a sense of agency. Instead of asking “will there be a deal before November 3?”, ask “what do I do in each of these three cases: a deal, no deal, or a partial deal on steel but not autos?” For each case, write down one concrete step: a price you will charge, an order you will delay, a conversation you will have with a supplier or an employer. The steps do not need to be big. They need to exist.

A second useful practice is to ration the news. Choose two moments in the day to check trade headlines, and treat anything outside those windows as noise until the next check. This breaks the intermittent reinforcement loop that keeps the alarm ringing.

A third practice is to separate what you can influence from what you cannot. You cannot decide whether Lutnick and LeBlanc reach an agreement this week. You can decide how you price next month’s orders, what you say to your team, and how much of your evening you hand over to speculation. Writing those two lists down, even briefly, tends to shrink the worry, because it moves the problem from a vague dread to a bounded set of actions.

Reflection: which headline are you actually waiting for?

Pause and notice what you are really checking for. Is it information you will act on, or reassurance that the worry will end? If it is reassurance, no single headline can deliver it, because the next headline could always reverse it. That is the trap of uncertainty: it promises that one more update will settle things, and it never does. The settlement comes from your plan, not from the news.

Try it on our site

If tariff and money news is keeping your mind spinning, try the tools at Zentha Psychology’s Wellness Tools hub (zenthapsychology.com/wellness-tools/): the Money-Stress Check gives you a private snapshot of how financial pressure is showing up for you, and the Thought Reframe tool walks you through turning a looping worry into a workable next step. Both are free, anonymous, and take only a few minutes.

Frequently asked questions

Are the US and Canada close to a trade deal?

Talks have intensified slightly, according to Prime Minister Mark Carney on October 26, 2026, and Reuters reported on October 27 that a deal to ease steel and auto tariffs is being worked on. But CBC reported that Canadian officials expect no deal before the November 3 midterm elections. The two accounts disagree, so a pre-election deal is possible but unconfirmed.

What tariffs are at the center of the Canada-US talks?

Tariffs imposed under Section 232 of US trade law, including up to 50 percent on Canadian steel and 25 percent on autos. Trump imposed 50 percent tariffs on roughly $20 billion in Canadian goods after talks broke down in August 2026, and later said he would lift some of those tariffs while imposing new ones on other products.

When are the US midterm elections in 2026?

November 3, 2026. The timing matters because Trump has suggested a deal could come before the midterms, while Canadian officials have signaled they will not rush into an agreement that crosses Canada’s red lines.

Why does tariff uncertainty cause so much anxiety?

Because of intolerance of uncertainty and ambiguity aversion: the brain treats an unresolved threat as an ongoing emergency, scanning for updates and rehearsing multiple futures at once. A definite outcome, even a bad one, lets people plan. An unresolved one keeps the alarm ringing, and unpredictable headlines reinforce the checking habit.

What helps with uncertainty anxiety?

Plan for scenarios instead of waiting for one answer: write down one concrete step for each plausible outcome. Ration news checks to set times of day, and separate what you can influence from what you cannot. These steps restore a sense of agency, which is exactly what uncertainty removes.

Key takeaways

  • Carney said on October 26, 2026, that trade talks have intensified slightly, but only because Washington is moving closer to Canada’s position.
  • Reuters reported on October 27 that a steel and auto tariff deal is being worked on; CBC reported that officials expect no deal before the November 3 midterms. Both cannot be the final word, and the outcome is unconfirmed.
  • Tariffs of up to 50 percent on steel and 25 percent on autos sit at the center of the talks, after an August breakdown and $20 billion in tariffed Canadian goods.
  • Uncertainty itself is the stressor: intolerance of uncertainty, ambiguity aversion, and intermittent headline reinforcement keep the brain’s alarm on.
  • The practical response is scenario planning, rationed news checks, and separating what you can influence from what you cannot.

If money or trade news is weighing heavily on you, in Canada you can call or text 988 for free, confidential support, day or night.

Educational disclaimer: This article is for general information only and is not medical, psychological, financial, or professional advice. It does not diagnose or treat any condition. If you are struggling, please consider speaking to a qualified professional or a trusted support service in your country.

Related reading: First Snow and the Psychology of Winter Arriving All at Once (zenthapsychology.com/first-snow-seven-states-winter-psychology/), The Psychology of Algorithm Anxiety (zenthapsychology.com/australia-aged-care-algorithm-anxiety/), Why the Clock Change Messes With Your Mind (zenthapsychology.com/psychology-of-daylight-saving-time/).

Leave a Comment