Grieving at the Holidays: How to Get Through Christmas Without Pretending You Are Fine
Reviewed by a Psychology Postgraduate (MA)
Grieving at the holidays is one of the most common and least talked-about kinds of pain. The short answer is this: the holidays hurt more, not less, after a loss, because every tradition is a reminder of who is missing — and the way through is not to force yourself to feel festive, but to plan the season deliberately, keep what still connects you to the person you lost, change what punishes you, and give yourself permission to step away when you need to. There is no right way to do a first Christmas without someone. There are only ways that are honest, survivable, and a little kinder to you than white-knuckling through December pretending nothing has changed.
The timing matters. Thanksgiving falls on 26 November this year, and the weeks between now and Christmas are when the dread usually peaks — often before the day itself arrives. If you are reading this in mid-November and already dreading the season, that dread is not a sign that you are failing at grief. Psychologists call it an anniversary reaction: in the weeks leading up to a significant date, memories sharpen, sleep gets worse, and mood dips, even when the loss itself happened months ago. That November dip is easy to confuse with seasonal depression, and the two can arrive together — but anniversary grief is tied to a date, not a season. The anticipation is frequently harder than the day. Knowing that in advance changes what you can do about it — because dread you can see coming is dread you can plan for.
Why do the holidays make grief sharper?
Why do the holidays make grief sharper? Because the holidays are built out of exactly the things grief disrupts: presence, ritual, and togetherness. A normal Tuesday in February does not ask anything of you. Christmas asks you to sit at a table with an empty chair, sing songs the person you lost used to sing, cook food they used to cook, and do it all while everyone around you performs happiness. The contrast is the wound. The world insists on joy in the season that most starkly shows you what is gone, and the gap between the performance and your reality can feel like loneliness at its sharpest — surrounded by people and still entirely alone.
Grief researchers describe this as absence in high relief. The psychiatrist Colin Murray Parkes wrote in 1971 that bereavement forces a revision of the assumed future — the life you expected to keep living, with that person in it. Holidays are the occasions that force that revision in public, on a date, in front of family. The smells, the songs, the decorations, the food: each one is a memory trigger, and each trigger lands at a moment when you are already depleted. The end of the year is also a time of taking stock, which means the losses of the year get counted at exactly the moment your energy is lowest. None of this means you are grieving wrong. It means the season is doing what seasons do, and grief is doing what grief does, at the same time.
Is the first holiday really the hardest?
Is the first holiday really the hardest? Often — but not always, and the exception matters. The first Thanksgiving without the person who carved the turkey, the first Christmas without their stocking, the first birthday after a loss: each is a threshold you cross for the first time, and the bereavement researcher Therese Rando called this the first year of firsts — learning, again and again, that the person will not be there. The first year carries a particular disorientation, and for many people it is the hardest year.
But many people find the second holiday harder in a specific way. In the first year, shock still insulates you, and other mourners are still close. By the second year, the shock has worn off, the wide circle of support has contracted, and the permanence of the absence is undeniable in a way it was not twelve months ago. If you are blindsided by the third, fifth, or tenth holiday after a loss, you are not failing to heal. Grief does not move in a straight line, and it does not observe a schedule. The holidays reopen grief on the same date every year, sometimes with unexpected intensity even long after the death, and that reopening is normal — not a relapse.
What does the research say actually helps?
What does the research say actually helps? The most useful framework comes from Margaret Stroebe and Henk Schut, whose dual process model of coping with bereavement (1999) describes grief as an oscillation between two kinds of work: loss-oriented coping — feeling the sadness, remembering, crying, missing them — and restoration-oriented coping — cooking the dinner, answering the emails, dealing with the practical business of the day. Healthy grieving is not staying in one or the other. It is moving back and forth. The people who struggle most are often the ones who get stuck at one pole: either drowning in the loss without ever coming up for air, or burying themselves in busyness so they never have to feel it.
That model predicts what tends to work at the holidays, and it is refreshingly practical. Give yourself deliberate time to grieve — a set time to remember, to cry, to look at photographs — and then give yourself deliberate time to do something else. Grief therapist Alan Wolfelt’s advice points the same way: plan the holiday in advance, rather than letting it happen to you. Decide beforehand which gatherings you will attend and which you will skip, how long you will stay, what you will say if someone asks how you are, and what your exit plan is. Advance planning substantially reduces anxiety, because the worst part of holiday grief is often the feeling of having no control over a day that is going to hurt — and a mind with no control fills the gap by overthinking every detail of it. A plan does not remove the hurt. It returns a measure of choice.
A second line of research changes how you think about the person you lost. Dennis Klass and colleagues, in Continuing Bonds (1996), showed that staying connected to the deceased — through memory, ritual, conversation, and the things they loved — is a normal and healthy part of grief, not a failure to let go. At the holidays, that might mean cooking their dish, lighting a candle, telling a story about them at the table, or keeping their stocking up with a note inside. The point is not to pretend they are still here. It is to give the relationship a place at the table that is honest rather than silent. Families that name the absence usually find the day easier than families that agree, without saying so, never to mention it.
Pause and ask yourself: Which part of the coming holiday are you actually dreading — a specific moment, a specific empty chair, a specific tradition? And what is one small change to that one moment that would make it survivable: shorter, quieter, shared differently, or skipped entirely?
How do you handle the day itself?
How do you handle the day itself? Start by giving yourself explicit permission not to celebrate. You are not obliged to demonstrate joy, and honesty with the people around you is usually received better than people fear. A short, plain sentence works: “This Christmas is hard for me, and I might need to step out for a while.” Most families would rather hear that than watch you go quiet at the table and wonder what they did wrong.
Then make the practical choices before the day arrives. Keep the traditions that still feel connecting and change the ones that feel punishing — there is no rule that says Christmas must look the way it looked last year. Eat at a different time, open presents in a different order, take a walk between courses, or spend part of the day with friends instead of family. Build in an escape route: drive yourself so you can leave when you need to, agree a signal with one trusted person, and decide in advance how long you will stay. And schedule a window for the grief itself — fifteen or thirty minutes to remember properly, cry if it comes, and then return to the day. That sounds artificial, and it works precisely because it is deliberate: grief you have made room for is easier to carry than grief that ambushes you between courses.
If other people are grieving too, remember that grief makes people behave strangely, and that the same loss can look completely different in two members of one family. One person wants to talk about them constantly; another cannot bear to hear the name. One wants every tradition preserved exactly; another wants them all gone. None of them is wrong. The kindest thing a family can do is say, out loud, that different people will need different things this year — and then let them have it.
When is holiday grief something more than grief?
When is holiday grief something more than grief? Most holiday grief, however intense, is normal grief, and it eases — unevenly, with setbacks — over time. But a minority of bereaved people develop what clinicians now call prolonged grief disorder: grief that stays all-consuming, most of the day, for more than twelve months in adults, with intense yearning, difficulty accepting the death, emotional numbness, and a sense that life has lost meaning. Research estimates put it at roughly 7 to 10 percent of bereaved adults. The signs to watch for are grief that does not shift at all over a year, complete withdrawal from other people, a sharp deterioration in sleep, eating or self-care, hopelessness, or intense guilt that will not move.
That distinction matters because the help is different. General counselling offered preventively to all bereaved people has weak evidence behind it — most people do not need it, and time and support do the work. But structured grief treatment for prolonged grief has good evidence (Wittouck and colleagues, 2011): specific, time-limited therapy that works directly with the loss. If the holidays are not the only hard time — if every day is the hard time, a year or more after the loss — that is worth taking to a professional, not as a failure but as the right tool for the right problem. If you feel you may not be able to stay safe, call or text 988 in the US, Samaritans on 116 123 in the UK, or 1737 in New Zealand.
The holidays will come whether you are ready or not, and they will come again next year. That is the bleak part and also, quietly, the hopeful part: you do not have to get this Christmas right. You only have to get through it in a way you can live with, with one honest ritual, one boundary kept, and one person who knows how hard it is. Next year the chair will still be empty, and you will be a year further into learning how to live with that. Most people find, over time, that the season does not stop hurting — but it stops ambushing them. A plan, a kept tradition, a named absence, and permission to leave early: that is not a small thing. For a first Christmas without someone, it is everything.
Frequently asked questions
Why is grieving during the holidays so hard?
Because holidays are built from presence, ritual and togetherness — the exact things a loss disrupts. Traditions, songs, smells and food act as memory triggers, and the cultural expectation of joy creates a painful contrast with how you actually feel. Research also shows grief intensity often rises in the November to January window, and the weeks before a holiday are frequently harder than the day itself.
Is the first Christmas after a loss the hardest?
Often, but not always. The first year of firsts — the first Thanksgiving, Christmas and birthday without the person — carries a particular disorientation. But many people find the second holiday harder, because the shock has worn off and the support around them has thinned. Grief does not move in a straight line, and feeling blindsided years later is normal, not a failure to heal.
What is the dual process model of grief?
Stroebe and Schut’s dual process model (1999) says healthy grieving oscillates between loss-oriented coping — feeling the sadness, remembering, missing the person — and restoration-oriented coping — handling the practical business of daily life. Getting stuck at either pole makes grief harder; moving back and forth between them is how most people get through.
Should I keep or change holiday traditions after a loss?
Keep the ones that still feel connecting and change the ones that feel punishing. There is no rule that Christmas must look like last year. Research on continuing bonds (Klass and colleagues, 1996) shows that keeping the person present through a dish, a story or a ritual is healthy — while changing the timing, the guest list or the order of the day can make an unbearable tradition survivable.
When should I seek professional help for grief?
If grief stays all-consuming most of the day for more than twelve months, with intense yearning, difficulty accepting the death, emotional numbness or a loss of meaning, it may be prolonged grief disorder, which affects roughly 7 to 10 percent of bereaved adults. Structured grief therapy has good evidence for this; general counselling offered to everyone does not. If you feel unsafe, call or text 988 in the US, Samaritans on 116 123 in the UK, or 1737 in New Zealand.
Try it on our site
Grief is easier to carry when something helps you name what you are feeling. Try these free, no-signup tools on Zentha Psychology:
- Mind Check-Ins — 27 one-minute check-ins, including loneliness and mood, to name where you are today.
- Daily Tracker — log your mood each day and watch how the season moves it, rather than guessing.
- Thought Reframe — practise holding two true things at once: the grief is real, and so is the rest of your life.
- Sleep Reset — a wind-down routine for the nights when grief keeps you awake, including an evening reflection.
Related reading: Dai Henwood Dies at 48: The Psychology of Grieving Someone You Never Met · RJ Mitte and the Grief for a Childhood Hero
Key Takeaways
- Holiday grief is normal and common: traditions make absence visible, and the weeks before a holiday are often harder than the day itself.
- The first year of firsts is disorienting, but the second holiday can be harder as shock wears off and support thins — grief does not move in a straight line.
- Stroebe and Schut’s dual process model says healthy grieving oscillates between feeling the loss and handling daily life; getting stuck at either pole makes it harder.
- Advance planning is the most practical help: decide what you will attend, how long you will stay, and how you will leave — and keep the traditions that connect you while changing the ones that punish you.
- Continuing bonds — a dish, a story, a candle — keep the person present honestly, and families that name the absence cope better than families that avoid it.
- If grief stays all-consuming for more than twelve months, it may be prolonged grief disorder, and structured grief therapy has good evidence for it.
This article is educational and is not a substitute for professional advice. If you are struggling, consider speaking with a licensed mental health professional. In the US, call or text 988. In the UK, Samaritans can be reached at 116 123. In New Zealand, call or text 1737.