Carney Says Canada Is Not Ready to Sign a US Trade Deal Yet: The Psychology of Waiting for a Deal That Never Lands

Carney Says Canada Is Not Ready to Sign a US Trade Deal Yet: The Psychology of Waiting for a Deal That Never Lands

Reviewed by a Psychology Postgraduate (MA)

Canada is not in a position yet to finalize a US trade deal, Prime Minister Mark Carney said on 29 October 2026, according to local media reports. Speaking to reporters ahead of a Liberal caucus meeting, Carney said Ottawa is looking for “the right deal for Canadians”, adding: “There are deals that are in the best interests of Canada, first and foremost, but also are in the interests of the United States. If those deals present themselves, we will pursue them. But we’re not at that position right now.”

The remarks land at a delicate moment. Questions have mounted over whether a deal could be reached before the US midterm elections on 3 November, and recent comments by US President Donald Trump claiming rapid progress toward an agreement have drawn close scrutiny in Ottawa — scrutiny that suggests the two capitals are not describing the same negotiation. Earlier in October, Carney and Ontario Premier Doug Ford announced a C$8.7 billion support plan for tariff-hit steel, automotive, and critical mineral sectors, including a joint steel action fund, help for automakers upgrading production lines for connected and electric vehicles, and infrastructure to build a critical mineral supply chain in northern Ontario. At the same time, Canada and the European Union opened two days of talks in Montreal on 29 October, with leaders aiming for an “ever closer association” after dropping a disputed “associate member” label from their draft declaration.

The short answer: Prolonged uncertainty is psychologically harder than bad news, because bad news lets you plan and uncertainty does not. When a trade deal is always “nearly there” but never signed, workers, businesses, and families cannot decide whether to hire, invest, move, or wait — and the brain treats that open-ended waiting as a threat in itself. Carney’s message, read psychologically, is an attempt to replace false hope with honest waiting: no deal yet, but a clear standard for what a good one looks like.

Anticipatory stress is the strain of waiting for an outcome that may or may not arrive, when the brain stays on high alert because it cannot prepare for an unknown.

Uncertainty is not just unpleasant; it is measurable. In laboratory studies, people show stronger stress responses when a shock might or might not arrive than when they know it definitely will. The reason is that the brain cannot prepare for an unknown — it stays on alert, rehearsing every version of the future at once. A trade negotiation that stretches across months, with conflicting signals from two governments, is that laboratory experiment playing out at national scale.

Why is waiting for a Canada trade deal worse than a clear no?

Imagine two factory workers in Ontario’s steel belt. One is told the plant will close in three months. The other is told a trade deal might save the plant, might not, and nobody knows when the answer will come. Research on anticipatory stress predicts the second worker sleeps worse. The first can grieve, plan, and act. The second can only wait, and waiting without a deadline is one of the most draining states the mind can occupy.

This is the psychology behind Carney’s careful wording. By saying plainly that Canada is “not at that position right now”, he is doing something counterintuitive: delivering disappointing news in order to reduce uncertainty. A clear “not yet” is kinder to the nervous system than a vague “soon”, because it stops the daily cycle of hope and deflation. Hope deferred, as the old proverb has it, makes the heart sick — and in negotiation psychology, repeated near-misses are more demoralising than a single rejection, because each near-miss reopens the wound.

Trump’s claims of rapid progress, set against Carney’s correction, create a second psychological problem: conflicting authorities. When two trusted sources describe the same reality differently, people do not split the difference — they pick the version that fits their existing fears or hopes, and they trust both sources a little less afterwards. Over months, that erosion of trust becomes its own cost, separate from tariffs themselves.

What does waiting do to businesses and families?

For businesses, uncertainty has a specific behavioral effect: it freezes decisions. Economists call this the option value of waiting — when the future is unclear, the rational move is often to delay investment until the fog clears. But what is rational for a firm is punishing for its workers, who experience the freeze as stalled promotions, unfilled vacancies, and overtime without hiring. Ontario’s C$8.7 billion support plan is, in psychological terms, an attempt to break that freeze: by funding steel, auto, and critical mineral projects directly, the government gives firms something concrete to plan around even while the trade talks drift.

For families, the freeze shows up differently. A household deciding whether to buy a car, move for a job, or take on a mortgage cannot wait forever, so it improvises — delaying the big purchase, cutting back on small pleasures, arguing about money more often. Financial psychologists call this precautionary saving, and it is sensible, but it has a mood cost: life lived in precaution feels smaller and grayer than life lived on a plan, even when the bank balance is healthier.

Pause and ask yourself: Is there a decision in your life right now that you are postponing because you are waiting for news — a job, a move, a purchase? Write down the smallest version of that decision you could make this week without the news. Waiting for certainty often costs more than deciding under uncertainty.

Try the Burnout and Money-Stress Check to separate the worry from the numbers →

Why is Canada turning to Europe at the same time?

The Montreal summit opening on 29 October is best understood as diversification psychology: when one relationship becomes unreliable, healthy systems build alternatives rather than waiting passively. Canada sends nearly 70% of its exports to the United States, while the European Union accounts for about 9% of its total trade. Closing that gap will take years, not a summit. But the act of opening a second front — with European Council President António Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen — changes the psychology of the US negotiation itself.

Negotiation research is clear on this point: your power in a negotiation depends largely on your best alternative to a negotiated agreement. A country with no alternative must accept whatever is offered. A country visibly building alternatives can afford to say “not yet”. Carney’s “right deal for Canadians” line and the Montreal summit are two halves of the same message: Canada is not desperate, and it is not idle. Whether that message lands in Washington is a political question. Psychologically, it matters at home too, because it gives Canadians a story other than helpless waiting — a story of a country widening its options.

There is a caution here as well. The summit dropped the “associate member” label after objections, including from Germany, that the status had no legal definition. That is a useful reminder that alternative relationships take the same slow, frustrating work as the original one. Diversification is not an escape from negotiation; it is more negotiation, with more partners.

How do you cope with a long, uncertain wait?

First, set your own deadline. If the news has no date, give your decision one: “If there is no deal by this date, I will act on the information I have.” Self-imposed deadlines restore the one thing uncertainty takes away — a sense of control over timing.

Second, separate what you can influence from what you cannot. You cannot speed up a trade negotiation. You can update a resume, build a small emergency buffer, or learn a skill that travels across industries. Action on the controllable side shrinks the uncontrollable side’s power over your mood.

Third, limit the news check. Trade headlines arrive daily and change little; checking them hourly trains the brain to treat every rumour as an event. One check a day, from a reliable source, is enough to stay informed without staying anxious.

Fourth, watch for the moment waiting becomes the plan. If months pass and every decision is still “on hold pending the deal”, the wait itself has become the problem. At that point, the psychologically honest move is to plan for the most likely outcome rather than the best one — and to revisit the plan if the news improves.

Frequently asked questions

What did Mark Carney say about a US trade deal? On 29 October 2026, Carney said Canada is not yet in a position to finalize a trade agreement with the United States, and that Ottawa will pursue a deal only if it is the right deal for Canadians.

Could a deal be signed before the US midterms? Following Carney’s statement, a deal before the 3 November 2026 midterm elections appears unlikely, though US and Canadian trade officials continue to talk.

What is the C$8.7 billion Ontario plan? A joint plan announced earlier in October 2026 by Carney and Ontario Premier Doug Ford to support tariff-hit steel, automotive, and critical mineral sectors, including a joint steel fund and EV production line upgrades.

What is happening at the Canada-EU summit? Canada and the EU opened two days of talks in Montreal on 29 October 2026, aiming for an “ever closer association” after dropping a disputed “associate member” label from their draft declaration.

Why is uncertainty worse than bad news? Research on anticipatory stress shows the brain stays on high alert when an outcome is unknown, rehearsing every version of the future — while bad news, however unwelcome, allows planning and adjustment.

Try it on our site

If money and work news is weighing on you, try these free tools — no signup needed: Burnout and Money-Stress Check, Anxiety and Mood Check-In, Thought Reframe, and Daily Tracker.

Related reading: Your Bank Just Raised Your Rate to 4.70% Overnight · Bank of Canada Raised Rates to 2.5% · The Fed Held Rates at 3.75% to 4%

Key Takeaways

  • On 29 October 2026, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Canada is not yet in a position to sign a US trade deal, seeking “the right deal for Canadians” rather than a rushed one.
  • A deal before the 3 November US midterms now appears unlikely, despite US claims of rapid progress — a conflict of signals that itself erodes trust.
  • Prolonged uncertainty is psychologically harder than bad news, because it prevents planning and keeps the brain on permanent alert.
  • Ontario’s C$8.7 billion support plan and the Montreal Canada-EU summit are both attempts to break the freeze: concrete action and wider options while talks drift.
  • Coping with an open-ended wait means setting your own deadlines, acting on what you control, and limiting news checks to once a day.

This article is for education only and is not therapy, diagnosis, or medical advice. If you are struggling, consider speaking to a licensed professional. In Canada, call or text 988.

Leave a Comment