AI Has Made Fake Ads Almost Impossible to Spot: The Psychology of Holiday Shopping Scams

AI Has Made Fake Ads Almost Impossible to Spot: The Psychology of Holiday Shopping Scams

Reviewed by a Psychology Postgraduate (MA)

More than eight in ten Canadians now say artificial intelligence has made fake ads harder to spot, according to the Royal Bank of Canada’s 2026 Holiday Shopping Scams Poll, published on 16 November 2026. The numbers are stark: 84 per cent say AI has made fake ads harder to spot, 82 per cent say the same about fake online retailers, and 77 per cent say fake celebrity and influencer endorsements are harder to catch. Nearly three in four — 72 per cent — say AI has made it almost impossible to know what is real versus fake when shopping online. With 71 per cent of Canadians planning to shop online for Black Friday and the holidays, and Black Friday itself just eleven days away on 27 November, the timing could hardly be worse.

AI fake ads psychology is the study of why a technology that was supposed to make shopping easier has instead made deception harder to detect. An AI-generated fake ad is a polished, professional-looking promotion for a product, retailer or deal that does not really exist — or does not exist in the form advertised — created with tools that can write flawless copy, generate convincing product photos, and even fake a celebrity’s face and voice. The short answer to why they work is uncomfortable: your brain was never good at spotting scams by looking at them. It spotted them by noticing what was wrong — the spelling errors, the blurry logos, the clumsy design. AI has removed all of that, and 67 per cent of Canadians in the RBC poll say exactly that: AI has removed the telltale signs of a scam.

This is not a Canadian problem alone. The same tools are flooding feeds in the US, the UK and Australia, and Salesforce projects that AI will drive $75.8 billion in Cyber Week spending globally this year, up 13 per cent on 2025. The shopping season that starts now is the first in which the fakes can look better than the real thing. Understanding why your brain falls for them is the only defence that still works.

What did the RBC poll actually find?

The RBC 2026 Holiday Shopping Scams Poll, released as Canadians begin their holiday shopping, paints a picture of a public that knows it is being targeted and does not trust its own defences. Half of respondents — 50 per cent — said they were confident they could spot an AI-generated shopping scam. The other half were not. Seven in ten (70 per cent) worry that they or someone they know will fall for a scam this holiday season, and 68 per cent worry scammers will collect their personal or financial information while they shop. Almost half, 45 per cent, are bracing to actually lose money.

The concern is sharpest on social media, where the RBC report says fake ads are especially rampant. Three quarters of Canadians (76 per cent) worry that the products, retailers and deals in their social feeds are AI-generated fakes, and 73 per cent are concerned that AI could recommend a fake retailer, product or deal to them directly — not just show them an ad, but actively steer them toward a scam. That last number matters, because it describes a new kind of risk: the recommendation itself can no longer be trusted as a neutral guide.

RBC has responded by adding AI-powered Scam Intercept Messages for Interac e-Transfers, a feature designed to warn customers before money moves. But the bank’s own vice-president of credit and fraud management, Amit Sadhu, put the problem plainly: fake websites, social media ads and marketplace posts, as well as AI-generated content, “are becoming more convincing, making it harder to know what’s real.” The poll’s message is not that shoppers are careless. It is that the cues they were trained to use have stopped working.

Why can’t our brains spot AI fakes anymore?

For decades, the advice for spotting a scam was visual: look for the typos, the odd web address, the stock photo that looks slightly wrong, the design that feels cheap. That advice worked because scammers were, on average, sloppy. AI has ended that era. A generated ad can have perfect grammar, a professional layout, a plausible web address and a product photo that looks better than the real thing. The cues are gone, and the brain has not yet developed replacements.

The reason goes deeper than the missing typos. Psychologists have long known about the fluency heuristic: things that are easy to process feel true. A clean, polished, well-written ad is easy to process, so it feels trustworthy — and an AI-generated ad is, by design, the easiest thing in your feed to process. The same mechanism explains why a celebrity endorsement works: it is a mental shortcut, a way of deciding without thinking. When the celebrity in the ad is AI-generated — a face and voice stitched together by a model — the shortcut still fires, because your brain recognises the face long before it questions the source. That is why 77 per cent of Canadians say fake endorsements are harder to spot: the part of the brain that checks “is this real?” is slower than the part that says “I know that face.”

There is also automation bias, the well-documented tendency to trust a machine’s output more than our own judgement. When a shopping app or a search result recommends a retailer, most people treat the recommendation as vetted — somebody, somewhere, must have checked this. AI recommendations inherit that trust automatically, even when no human has checked anything at all. The 73 per cent who worry AI could recommend a fake retailer are sensing a real shift: the guide itself has become a possible accomplice.

And then there is the truth bias. Research consistently finds that people default to believing what they read unless they have a specific reason not to. In a feed full of real deals, real shops and real friends, the default setting is trust — and a scam that looks exactly like everything else in the feed gets the benefit of that default for free. Scammers used to have to earn trust by looking legitimate. Now legitimacy is free, and trust is the default.

Why do fake ads work so well at Christmas?

The holiday season is the worst possible time for this problem, because it is also the season when the brain’s defences are weakest. Christmas shopping runs on urgency: limited-time deals, countdown timers, “only two left in stock”, prices that expire at midnight. Scarcity and urgency are two of the most powerful persuasion levers in psychology — they short-circuit careful thinking by making delay feel costly. A shopper who would normally pause and check a retailer’s reviews does not pause when the timer says three minutes left. The psychology of Black Friday shopping runs on exactly this mechanism: the fear of missing a deal overwhelms the caution that would normally catch a fake.

Money pressure makes it worse. The holiday season is when budgets are tightest and the desire to find a bargain is strongest, and a fake deal that is 70 per cent off is far more tempting to a person who is already anxious about affording Christmas than to someone shopping casually. The same inflation anxiety that has been squeezing households all year makes the too-good-to-be-true offer feel like a rescue rather than a warning. Loss aversion does the rest: the brain weighs losing a bargain more heavily than it weighs the risk of being scammed, so it clicks first and checks later — if it checks at all.

Decision fatigue is the third ingredient. By late November, most people have made hundreds of small shopping decisions, compared prices across a dozen tabs, and scrolled past thousands of ads. The mental energy that careful checking requires is simply gone. Research on ego depletion — the idea that self-control and careful thinking draw on a limited resource — predicts exactly this: after a long day of decisions, people default to the easiest option, and the easiest option is to trust the polished ad in front of them. Scammers do not need to beat your best thinking. They only need to catch you at 9 p.m. after a long day, when your best thinking has already gone home.

Pause and ask yourself: Think of the last ad you almost clicked on. What made it tempting — the price, the countdown, the face in it, or the feeling that everyone else was already buying? Name the lever. Scams work by pulling levers; naming the lever is how you stop pulling it yourself.

Try the Burnout + Money-Stress Check

AI fake ads psychology: a painted illustration of a shopper staring at a phone full of glowing, too-good-to-be-true holiday ads

How can you spot an AI-generated shopping scam?

You cannot spot one by looking at it anymore. That is the honest starting point, and it is the reason the old advice has failed. What still works is a set of habits that do not depend on your eyes at all:

  1. Never buy from the ad itself. Close the ad, open a browser, and search for the retailer by name. If the shop is real, it will exist outside its own advertisement. If the only trace of it is the ad, walk away.
  2. Check the deal against the real price. Search for the same product on a retailer’s site you already trust. If the advertised price is 70 per cent lower than everywhere else, it is not a bargain — it is bait. Real retailers do not sell at a loss to strangers.
  3. Reverse-search the image. Save the product photo and run it through a reverse image search. AI-generated product shots often appear on multiple unrelated sites, or nowhere at all except the ad.
  4. Read the web address slowly. AI can polish an ad, but it cannot fake a domain. Look for slight misspellings, extra words, or unfamiliar endings on a familiar brand name. Then type the brand’s real address yourself rather than clicking through.
  5. Slow down the urgency. A countdown timer is a persuasion tool, not a fact. Close the tab, wait an hour, and see whether the “deal” is still there. Real offers survive an hour. Scams rely on you not taking one.
  6. Pay with protection. Use a credit card or a payment method with buyer protection, never a direct bank transfer, gift card or cryptocurrency. If a seller only accepts unprotected payment, that is the answer: it is a scam.
  7. Check the celebrity. If a famous face is selling something surprising, search for the endorsement on a reputable news site. AI-generated celebrity ads are now common enough that the feeds most of us scroll every night carry them daily — and a thirty-second search is usually enough to expose them.

The deeper habit is the one the RBC poll points to: assume that looking is not enough. The generation that learned to spot scams by their appearance is now shopping in a world where appearance has been automated. The defence that replaces it is procedural — slow down, leave the app, verify outside it, and pay in a way that can be reversed. None of that is exciting. All of it works. And if the money pressure behind the bargain-hunting is the real driver, that is worth addressing directly too: the silence around money stress makes it worse, and naming it is the first step to shopping from a plan instead of from panic.

Frequently asked questions

What is an AI fake ad?
An AI fake ad is a polished, professional-looking promotion for a product, retailer or deal that does not really exist — or does not exist as advertised — created with AI tools that can write flawless copy, generate convincing product photos and even fake a celebrity’s face and voice.

Why are AI fake ads so hard to spot?
Because the old warning signs — spelling errors, bad design, blurry logos — have been removed. AI generates clean, professional ads, and the brain’s fluency heuristic makes easy-to-process content feel trustworthy. 67 per cent of Canadians in the RBC poll say AI has removed the telltale signs of a scam.

What did the RBC 2026 Holiday Shopping Scams Poll find?
84 per cent of Canadians say AI makes fake ads harder to spot, 82 per cent say fake online retailers are harder to spot, 72 per cent say AI makes it almost impossible to know what is real versus fake when shopping online, and only 50 per cent feel confident they could spot an AI-generated shopping scam.

How can I protect myself from holiday shopping scams?
Never buy from the ad itself — search for the retailer independently, check the price against a trusted store, reverse-search product images, read web addresses carefully, ignore countdown timers, and pay only with a protected method such as a credit card.

Try it on our site

These free tools can help you pause, reflect and reset. No signup needed.

Related reading: Black Friday Shopping Psychology: Why We Buy Things We Don’t Need · Australia’s Inflation Anxiety: The Psychology of Rising Prices · The UK Cost of Silence: Why We Don’t Talk About Money

Key Takeaways

  • RBC’s 2026 Holiday Shopping Scams Poll, published 16 November 2026, found 84% of Canadians say AI makes fake ads harder to spot, and 72% say AI makes it almost impossible to know what is real versus fake when shopping online.
  • Only half of Canadians feel confident they could spot an AI-generated shopping scam, and 70% worry they or someone they know will fall for one this holiday season.
  • AI fakes work because they remove the old warning signs: the fluency heuristic makes polished ads feel true, automation bias makes recommendations feel vetted, and truth bias gives lookalike scams the benefit of the doubt.
  • The holidays make it worse: scarcity, urgency, money pressure and decision fatigue all weaken the careful thinking that catching a scam requires.
  • Looking is no longer enough. The defence is procedural: leave the ad, verify the retailer independently, ignore countdown timers, and pay only with a protected method.

This article is for education only, not therapy, diagnosis, or medical advice. If you are struggling, consider speaking with a licensed professional. In the US, call or text 988 for the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, free and 24/7. In Canada, call or text 988 for the Suicide Prevention Helpline. In the UK or Ireland, call Samaritans on 116 123.

Leave a Comment